Guess The Genre #1869 (Gathered by Ken Anderson)

Attic Toys Aerosmith Attic Dream Richard Thompson
Attic Songs Billy Joel Attic Light Rick Tedesco
Attic Eastside Milwaukee Various Attic Songs Jim Lloyd
Attic Christmas Trans Siberian Orch Attic Christmas Box
Attic Pollyannas Carolyn Arends Attic Up Alien Ant Farm

Answer: The Attic - Next is Guess the Genre #1870

Or, I don't want to guess - Show Me A List